Biogas and biomethane are two stages in renewable gas production. Each has its own makeup and uses that make them valuable for our clean energy future.

Biogas vs biomethane: Key differences

Biogas is a raw gas mixture that comes from anaerobic digestion. This happens when microorganisms break down organic matter without oxygen. The unrefined gas has about 45-85% methane and 25-50% carbon dioxide, plus tiny amounts of other gasses. Biomethane, on the other hand, is biogas that’s been purified or “upgraded.” The process removes carbon dioxide and other unwanted elements to create an almost pure methane product.

These gasses differ mainly in how pure they are. Here are the main differences:

• A methanization unit produces biogas that contains about 60% methane and 40% CO2
• The purification process removes carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, water, and other impurities from biomethane
• Biomethane naturally fits into existing natural gas systems because it has more methane

Technologies like water scrubbing and membrane separation turn limited-use biogas into versatile biomethane. The end product is exactly like conventional natural gas.

Why biomethane is considered renewable natural gas

Biomethane gets its renewable natural gas (RNG) status because it comes from organic materials that keep growing back. These include food waste, leftover crops, manure, sewage sludge, and anything else that breaks down naturally. The EPA officially calls biomethane RNG that’s been upgraded to replace regular natural gas.

Biomethane’s carbon footprint makes it special. When you burn it, it releases about the same amount of greenhouse gasses that you saved by turning waste into energy. This creates an almost neutral carbon cycle, which makes it much better for the environment than fossil fuels.

The production process helps create a circular economy by managing organic waste well. Farmers can use the leftover digestates as fertilizers, which means they need fewer chemical ones.

Overview of biomethane fuel properties

Biomethane works just like natural gas because they share similar properties. It packs quite a punch with its energy content – about 36 MJ/m³.

The gas becomes incredibly versatile after upgrading, with methane levels hitting above 97%. Production plants that meet certain standards can get official certification through a Guarantee of Origin (GO) and a Proof of Sustainability (PoS).

Biomethane works everywhere. People use it in homes and factories instead of natural gas. It powers electricity and heat generation, runs vehicles as an advanced renewable biofuel, and even helps make renewable hydrogen.

Cars and trucks can run on biomethane as compressed natural gas (CNG) or liquefied natural gas (LNG) without any changes to their engines. This makes it perfect for cutting emissions in transportation right now.

The Biomethane Production Process Explained

The process of turning organic waste into usable biomethane fuel combines several sophisticated processes that work together seamlessly. The technical marvel behind this renewable energy source becomes clear when we understand how biomethane production works.

Anaerobic digestion and biogas generation

Anaerobic digestion serves as the foundation of most biomethane production. The process takes place in sealed vessels called reactors that are designed for specific site and feedstock conditions. This biological process happens in four distinct stages:

• Hydrolysis: Complex organic compounds like proteins, fats, and carbohydrates break down into simpler molecules such as amino acids, fatty acids, and sugars
• Acidogenesis: Fermentative bacteria convert these simpler compounds into short-chain organic acids, alcohols, and gasses
• Acetogenesis: Bacteria transform compounds from the previous stage into substances that methanogenic microbes can process
• Methanogenesis: Strictly anaerobic archaea produce methane, with approximately 70% coming from acetoclastic methanogens and 30% from hydrogenotrophic methanogens

The biogas that results from this process typically contains 50-75% methane, 25-50% carbon dioxide, and trace amounts of other gasses.

Upgrading biogas to biomethane

Biogas upgrading produces about 90% of all biomethane worldwide. This process purifies raw biogas to meet natural gas standards. The process starts by removing contaminants through:

1. Filtration and dehumidification to remove water and pollutants
2. Purification through activated carbon beds to eliminate hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs)
3. Separation of methane from carbon dioxide

Water scrubbing and membrane separation are the most common upgrading technologies. These methods account for nearly 60% of global biomethane production. The final product contains 95-99% methane.

Alternative methods: Gasification and methanation

Thermal gasification provides another path to biomethane production besides anaerobic digestion. This method converts woody biomass or solid biomass into synthetic gas at high temperature and pressure in an oxygen-deprived environment. The resulting syngas goes through a cleaning process to remove acidic components. A catalyst then promotes a reaction between hydrogen and carbon monoxide or CO₂ to produce methane during methanation.

Biogas direct methanation has emerged as a promising alternative. This method skips the CO₂ separation step and produces up to 80% more renewable methane than conventional upgrading methods.

Biomethane production from biogas: Step-by-step

The complete biomethane production follows these key steps:

1. Collection and pre-treatment of organic feedstock (agricultural waste, food waste, manure, or sewage sludge)
2. Anaerobic digestion in temperature-controlled (35-55°C) oxygen-free environments
3. Biogas collection containing 50-75% methane
4. Preliminary cleaning to remove moisture and sulfur compounds
5. Upgrading through technologies like membrane separation or water scrubbing
6. Quality verification to ensure 97-99% methane content
7. Compression or liquefaction for transport or grid injection

Green Gas Inc’s projects achieve final biomethane purity levels above 97%. This makes the product fully compatible with existing natural gas infrastructure.

Feedstocks and Technologies Used in Biomethane Plants

Biomethane production can use many types of organic materials as feedstock. The efficiency and economic success of biomethane plants in the United States depend on choosing the right inputs and technologies.

Common feedstocks: Manure, crop residues, MSW

The right feedstock choices are the foundations of any successful biomethane project. Livestock manure is the most common input, though it yields less biogas than other materials. American cattle farms can generate about 40.15 tons of potential feedstock yearly, while poultry

operations provide around 0.58 tons.

Agricultural residues show great potential, with wheat, barley, and corn leading the way in American farming operations. These crop residues, along with animal manure, make up the largest feedstock sources. This is especially true in regions with strong agricultural sectors.

Municipal solid waste (MSW) adds substantially to the feedstock mix. Population growth and changing consumption patterns keep reshaping waste composition. The organic portion of MSW gives biomethane plants valuable inputs when they need diverse feedstock sources.

Role of wastewater sludge and food waste

Municipal treatment plants’ wastewater sludge shows different biomethane potential. Primary sludge generates about 0.425 Nm³ per kg of volatile solids—much higher than mixed sludge (0.296) or activated sludge (0.176).

Food waste works great as a co-substrate in anaerobic co-digestion (AcoD). It pairs well with nutrient-rich sewage sludge. Food waste’s high biodegradability boosts biogas production without much impact on biosolid management needs.

Technology types: Digesters, gasifiers, upgrading units

Anaerobic digestion technologies change based on feedstock characteristics. Each reactor design makes microbial activity work better for specific inputs. Some regions use household biodigesters with pig manure, which shows why reliable feedstock supply matters.

Gasification technology isn’t as mature as anaerobic digestion but offers another option. It works particularly well for woody biomass that traditional digestion can’t process effectively.

Upgrading relies on four main technologies: membrane separation, pressure swing adsorption (PSA), amine scrubbing, and water wash. These methods separate CO₂ from methane by using molecular properties and charge differences.

Sustainability considerations in feedstock selection

Choosing sustainable feedstock needs careful evaluation of several factors: adequacy (quantity and suitability), supply consistency (seasonality, alternative uses, storability), and logistical ease (collection, operational storage, preprocessing).

Green Gas Inc backs projects that use local, green feedstocks. These minimize environmental effects while maximizing biomethane yield. Currently, the focus stays on waste and residues instead of dedicated energy crops to avoid land-use conflicts.

Applications of Biomethane Across Sectors

Biomethane stands out as an exceptional renewable energy source that powers applications of all types in the United States. This clean alternative to natural gas opens up decarbonization opportunities in multiple sectors without needing major infrastructure changes.

Residential and industrial heating

The existing natural gas grids can directly use biomethane, which makes it a continuous heating solution for homes, businesses, and industrial facilities. Biomethane shares similar properties with natural gas and burns cleaner, cutting carbon emissions by up to 81% compared to fossil fuels. Space heating makes up almost 80% of household energy use in many regions, making this a meaningful way to achieve climate goals.

Electricity generation and CHP systems

Today, about two-thirds of biogas production generates electricity and heat, with roughly 18 GW of installed power generation capacity worldwide. Combined heat and power (CHP) systems work better by producing electricity and thermal energy at the same time. These systems convert 35% of energy into electricity and capture 40-50% as useful heat. Industries with organic waste streams benefit greatly from these systems that treat waste and provide on-site energy.

Biomethane in transport: CNG and LNG vehicles

The transportation sector uses compressed (bio-CNG) or liquefied (bio-LNG) biomethane to power vehicles with small changes to natural gas engines. Fleet operators across the United States switch to this option faster as they look for cleaner alternatives. Vehicles running on biomethane cut greenhouse gas emissions by a lot compared to diesel. They can even achieve negative emissions when they capture methane from waste sources.

Use in agriculture and rural energy systems

Biogas systems create ideal circular economy opportunities in agriculture. Farmers can spread digestate from these systems on their land as fertilizer, which reduces their need for fossil-based options. They can also earn money by turning waste into energy while improving their waste management. Rural communities benefit from these local energy systems that improve energy security with locally-produced fuel.

Biomethane as a hydrogen feedstock

The National Renewable Energy Laboratory estimates U.S. biomethane could produce about 4.2 million metric tons of renewable hydrogen yearly. This new application reforms biomethane into hydrogen, creating a practical path to renewable hydrogen production using reliable infrastructure. The process could later include carbon capture, leading to negative emissions when biogenic CO₂ gets stored underground.

Environmental and Economic Benefits of Biomethane

Biomethane offers technical advantages and brings remarkable environmental and economic benefits. These benefits make it the life-blood of eco-friendly energy development in the United States.

Reducing greenhouse gas emissions

Biomethane creates the most important emission reductions by replacing fossil fuels. This sometimes leads to carbon-negative systems. The numbers tell an impressive story—biomethane production saves up to 202% of greenhouse gas emissions compared to fossil fuels. A waste-to-wheels assessment shows that compressed natural gas from biogas cuts greenhouse gas emissions by up to 91% compared to petroleum gasoline.

Technology improvements expand these benefits even further. To name just one example, Bright Biomethane’s membrane technology achieves methane recovery of at least 99.5%. The methane loss stays minimal at just 0.5%. Biomethane could decrease emissions from natural gas systems by 11% if it replaces fossil natural gas. This equals 1.1 Gt CO2-eq each year.

Improving waste management and recycling

Biomethane production changes waste into valuable energy. This process keeps organic materials out of landfills where they would naturally break down and release methane—a greenhouse gas 84 times more harmful than CO2.

The process brings multiple benefits while solving waste challenges. The digestate left after anaerobic digestion works as an excellent biofertilizer. This reduces the need for energy-intensive chemical fertilizers. The process cuts production emissions and enhances soil quality through carbon sequestration.

Creating rural jobs and income streams

Biomethane production’s economic effect shines especially in rural areas. The United States could build 13,500 potential biogas systems that would create:

• Over 335,000 temporary construction jobs
• 23,000 permanent jobs
• Approximately $40 billion in capital development

Farmers can create new revenue streams through biomethane projects. They can lease land for plants, sell manure as feedstock, and market green biomass. Each facility can add $4-5 million to a farmer’s annual income.

Supporting the circular economy

Biomethane production shows circular economy principles at their best. The process handles three tasks at once: it treats waste, supplies energy, and produces fertilizers. One company’s waste becomes a valuable resource for another.

This circular approach works exceptionally well in agriculture. Farmers can apply digestate from biogas systems back to their cropland. These crops feed animals whose manure goes back into digestion. The cycle reduces fugitive emissions and improves soil’s organic content.

Biomethane Market Trends and U.S. Project Landscape

The U.S. biomethane market has grown remarkably. Production capacity has expanded over the last several years. This growth shows how biomethane is becoming a viable renewable energy solution across the country.

Current U.S. biomethane production capacity

U.S. biomethane production hit 3.1 billion cubic meters (bcm) from 275 facilities in 2023, which made America a global leader. Experts expect this number to reach 4 bcm in 2024, a big jump of 30% from last year. The U.S. now has about 2,500 biogas-producing sites spread across all states. These include 609 farm digesters, over 1,180 water resource recovery facilities, 113 food waste systems, and 583 landfill gas projects. The total capital investment in these facilities stands at $37.60 billion.

Policy support and incentives in the U.S.

Several key policies help stimulate biomethane production:

• The Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) with updated volume targets for cellulosic biogas
• California’s Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) that rewards lower carbon intensity of biomethane
• The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) offering tax credits for biomethane projects

California’s mandate to promote in-state biomethane production creates perfect conditions for new projects. Now, 95% of new biogas projects are built to upgrade to renewable natural gas (RNG).

Emerging biomethane projects in the U.S.

The industry saw 125 new biogas projects come online in 2024. This represents over $3 billion in new investments—40% more than last year. Farmers led the way with 93 new projects compared to 24 landfill projects. Air Liquide expanded its footprint with new production units in Pennsylvania and Michigan, set to produce 74 GWh from dairy farm waste.

Challenges in scaling infrastructure

The industry faces some tough hurdles. The most important barrier is the high capital investment needed for infrastructure. Getting pipeline connections and dealing with different state regulations also pose challenges. The industry could add 17,000 new sites, but this needs faster permits and strong political backing.

Green Gas Inc: Supporting local biomethane growth

Green Gas Inc turns organic waste into high-quality biogas and RNG. Industry veterans who developed some of the original dairy biogas and RNG projects in the U.S. founded the company. They’ve already completed 8 biogas-to-RNG projects. Their detailed “Development Process” guides projects from screening to operations. The company wants to develop assets that produce 30 billion standard cubic feet by 2030 through their “Target 30 by 30” initiative.

Conclusion

Conclusion

Biomethane production serves as a versatile, eco-friendly energy solution with huge growth potential in the United States. This piece showed how biomethane is fundamentally different from biogas due to its higher purity levels and better energy content. The complete production process—from anaerobic digestion to upgrading technologies—proves we can scale this renewable fuel source nationwide.

Biomethane’s environmental benefits are without doubt compelling. It reduces greenhouse gas emissions by up to 91% compared to petroleum gasoline. The applications range from residential heating and electricity generation to transportation and hydrogen production. This makes it a truly versatile energy solution.

The economic benefits make an even stronger case for biomethane. The industry could create 335,000 construction jobs and 23,000 permanent positions. This would refresh rural communities and generate new income for American farmers. Biomethane production shows how waste can become valuable resources in a circular economy.

U.S. biomethane market growth continues to impress. Production capacity grew from 3.1 billion cubic meters in 2023 to an expected 4 billion cubic meters this year. In spite of that, scaling infrastructure and navigating state regulations remain challenging.

Green Gas Inc leads this renewable energy revolution with complete development expertise for biomethane projects nationwide. Their “Target 30 by 30” initiative shows their commitment to expanding biomethane production across America.

The future looks promising for sustainable energy, and biomethane production is the life-blood of America’s renewable energy strategy. By controlling our abundant organic waste streams, we can tackle waste management challenges, cut emissions, and create domestic energy sources that help local communities. Biomethane’s time has come.

FAQs

Q1. What is the difference between biogas and biomethane? 

Biogas is a raw gas mixture produced through anaerobic digestion, containing 45-85% methane and 25-50% carbon dioxide. Biomethane, on the other hand, is purified biogas that has undergone upgrading to remove carbon dioxide and contaminants, resulting in a product that is almost 100% methane.

Q2. How does biomethane production benefit the environment? 

Biomethane production significantly reduces greenhouse gas emissions, with potential savings of up to 202% compared to fossil fuels. It also improves waste management by diverting organic materials from landfills and produces digestate that can be used as a biofertilizer, reducing dependency on chemical fertilizers.

Q3. What are the main applications of biomethane? 

Biomethane has various applications across sectors, including residential and industrial heating, electricity generation in combined heat and power (CHP) systems, transportation as compressed or liquefied natural gas, agricultural and rural energy systems, and as a feedstock for hydrogen production.

Q4. How is the biomethane market developing in the United States? 

The U.S. biomethane market is experiencing rapid growth, with production capacity reaching 3.1 billion cubic meters in 2023 and projected to increase to 4 billion cubic meters in 2024. The country has approximately 2,500 biogas-producing sites across all 50 states, with 125 new projects coming online in 2024 alone.

Q5. What are the economic benefits of biomethane production? Biomethane production creates significant economic opportunities, particularly in rural areas. It has the potential to generate over 335,000 temporary construction jobs and 23,000 permanent jobs in the United States. For farmers, biomethane projects can provide additional revenue streams, with some facilities generating an extra $4-5 million in annual income.

References

1. https://www.iea.org/reports/outlook-for-biogas-and-biomethane-prospects-for-organic-growth
2. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960852421003175
3. https://www.eesi.org/papers/view/fact-sheet-biogasconverting-waste-to-energy
4. https://www.nrdc.org/bio/darby-hoover/evaluating-anaerobic-digestion-municipal-organics-recycling
5. https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/18/7/1739
6. https://www.rabobank.com/knowledge/d011421992-a-fork-in-the-road-for-renewable-natural-gas-exploring-policy-developments
7. https://americanbiogascouncil.org/biogas-market-snapshot/
8. https://www.cedigaz.org/biomethane-biogas-renewable-natural-gas-rng/
9. https://www.ieabioenergy.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/2022_12_12-IEA_Bioenergy_position-paper_Final2.pdf
10. https://www.nrel.gov/